Scots Fall To Carleton In Final Minutes
By Tris Wykes
Macalester College home football games feature free admission, but those in attendance for Saturday’s Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference opener with Carleton would have gotten their more than their money’s worth even if they’d forked over a sawbuck or two.
The Knights claimed the schools’ Book of Knowledge trophy for a sixth consecutive time with a 48-45 victory that went down to the wire. Carleton quarterback Tyler Mastronardi completed five consecutive passes during his team’s final drive, the last a 4-yard touchdown toss past cornerback Patrick Webster to receiver Tyler Diamond with 20 seconds remaining.
The visitors’ last march covered 64 yards in only 82 seconds. It was aided by a questionable pass-interference penalty but exposed a Scots’ defensive secondary loaded with underclassmen.

Jack Scully signals in the background while David Frechette runs for the Scots’ final touchdown of the night.
Macalester suffered its eighth setback by three points or less in its last 22 games. Head coach Phil Nicolaides took no consolation from the fact that Carleton blew the Scots out last season, 51-7, but needed every last second Saturday to escape victorious from John Leaney Field.
“I’m not a moral victory guy,” said Nicolaides, whose team trailed by six points at halftime and by 12 midway through the third quarter. “We showed up to win the game and we failed, but I’m proud of how hard our guys battled.”
“It stings but you’re supposed to care so much that when you lose a close one, it does break your heart. I would have liked to have seen our seniors holding the Book of Knowledge and posing for pictures in front of the scoreboard.”
Part of the postgame frustration stemmed from Macalester’s special teams struggles and its inability to stop the Knights in crucial situations.
“We’re young in the secondary and we’re taking some lumps but they’re battling,” Nicolaides said of a unit that starts freshman Webster at one corner and inexperienced sophomore Addison Stirling at the other. Junior safety Jay Green, expected to anchor the defense’s back half, is out for the season with a torn knee ligament.
On Carleton’s second play from scrimmage, Diamond took a sweep handoff and threw a 40-yard touchdown to Cooper Pollard. Later in the first quarter, Diamond returned a kickoff 73 yards for a touchdown, but the teams ended the stanza tied 13-13 after Macalester’s Jack Scully threw scoring strikes to Tucker Snow and Kelly Storms.
The visitors used a 40-yard Jaxon Watson punt return to set up a short touchdown run, sandwiched by field goals from either team. The latter of those boots, a 28-yarder by Macalester’s Andrew Wetherill with nine seconds remaining in the half, was followed by an out-of-bounds kickoff that gave the Knights the ball at their own 45.
A completed pass moved Carleton to Macalester’s 43-yard line and from there Mastronardi heaved a pass into a back corner of the end zone, the ball descending over outstretched Macalester arms and into those of Knight Justin Sterner. The Scots had five defenders within a yard or two of the catch and Webster was the last of them that the ball passed. The visitors led at intermission, 29-23.
“That Hail Mary (pass) obviously can’t happen going into halftime,” Nicolaides said. “It’s one play here, one play there and we didn’t make enough of them.”
Diamond threw his second touchdown pass of the night four minutes into the third quarter, again on a trick play. Brennan Litchford answered for the Scots four minutes later with a 10-yard scoring run to pull his team within 35-30.
Macalester’s Willis Teagan punted out of his own end zone early in the final stanza and Watson returned this one 21 yards, setting up a Mastronardi touchdown sneak and a 41-30 lead. Scully then threw a 19-yard touchdown pass to Paxton Boyd with eight minutes to go and David Frechette ran 3 yards for another score with 1 minute, 49 seconds remaining on the clock.
Scully completed 22 of 34 passes for 267 yards and four touchdowns and had a last-ditch pass intercepted as time expired. He rushed for a career-high 87 yards and Nicolaides lauded him for his postgame encouragement of his teammates.
“I thought he battled his ass off and was extremely poised,” the coach said. “He didn’t put the ball in harm’s way and was pretty accurate. What a competitor; he’s the heartbeat of this team.”
The Boyd-Storms receiver duo each caught seven passes, the former for 133 yards and a touchdown and the latter for 62 yards and two touchdowns.
“Those two are incredible route runners who are always finding space, always getting open,” Scully said. “The three of us have a good connection on and off the field and it makes it fun to play with each other.”
Linebackers Jason Weaver and Dylan Jeppe each had six tackles and Andrew Frechette had two sacks. Litchford carried 20 times for 74 yards and Frechette ran 14 times for 57 yards, each back scoring a touchdown.
“I thought the backs both ran incredibly hard,” Nicolaides said. “It’s MIAC football so running the ball is going to be something we need to be able to do.”
Macalester’s offensive line lost right tackle Elijah Zapzalka to a first-half ankle or lower leg injury, causing starting senior center Bram Goldsmith to take his place and sophomore left guard Joey Falls to shift to center. Falls, however, suffered dehydration cramps as the game progressed, necessitating the use of freshmen Mete Ozkan and Parker Vendetti-Roux.
Offensive line coach Nolan Richardson “was moving guys around like chess pieces,” Nicolaides said. “We had guys playing who only got here a month ago.”
Senior defensive lineman Diego Agustin said he believes the Scots’ care for each other will be a major factor in rebounding next week against visiting St. Scholastica.
“This is a really resilient team,” Agustin said. “Sometimes you get young guys who get stuck on the depth chart and they give up and say wait until next year. It’s a testament that our young guys buy in right away and the older guys help them get up to speed so they can play right away.”
Nicolaides, in his fifth year at Macalester and now 12-30 overall and 3-19 in MIAC play, said trying to get over the hump is getting old.
“This team needs to take that next step and start winning these close games,” he said.
Notes: Agustin routinely wears thin, wide headbands under his helmet and one features the colors and logo of the Quebec Nordiques, a former NHL team. Agustin said his grandmother is from Quebec and that band is a nod to her heritage… Rex Desso, a 2023 Macalester graduate, is Carleton’s receivers coach and recruiting coordinator. The Coloradan helped Iowa’s Grand View University win last season’s NAIA national championship as its receivers coach. He was twice a first team All-MIAC selection who set school records for receptions in a game (18), season (100) and career (208) and the season mark for receiving yards (1,266)… Gerald Young, who returned to the Knights as defensive line coach this year, was previously an assistant coach at school for 17 years, 14 of them as defensive coordinator. He then served another 14 years as athletic director and retired from that job in 2024.

They wear their sunglasses at night so they can, so they can, watch you weave then breathe your story lines.


