Crowded QB Room Could Mean One On the Move
By Tris Wykes
Space is at a premium in the Macalester College quarterback room, with six signal callers at a position built for one.
Junior Jack Scully leads the group, having started every game last season, when the Scots were 3-7 overall and 2-7 in the Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference. He completed 52 percent of his passes last season for 1,809 yards, 13 touchdown and 11 interceptions.
Sophomore Ethan Pohl was the only other competitor to take a snap behind center in 2025, but registered no statistics. Others at the position include sophomores Mack Lee and Jack Brewer and freshmen Alex Kirkpatrick and Lucas Kaplan.
Head coach Phil Nicolaides said his ideal number of signal-callers is four or five and that one of the above players could be moved to a different position.
Lee did that last year, playing in two games as a linebacker and on special teams before returning to the offensive huddle during the spring. Nicolaides recalled that the 2025 Macalester defensive secondary featured two former quarterbacks and a onetime running back, because high schools tend to place their best and most reliable athletes at those positions.
“We’re letting those guys duke it out, but maybe there’s one who can help us elsewhere,” Nicolaides said. “It’s a position where only one guy can play and it’s not good to be overcrowded, either for a player’s experience or for coaches. People start to get a little less attention.
“It’s tough to get guys enough reps and we only have so much bandwidth as coaches.”
Friday’s intersquad scrimmage should produce position rankings, with Nicolaides looking for consistency from a group of reserve quarterbacks he said have shown flashes of brilliance.
“Guys have arm talent and all the physical traits, but quarterback is a tough position to master during preseason camp because there are so many sets and protections and reads to learn. It’s a lot to put on someone’s plate.”
*****
Speaking of quarterbacks playing other positions, senior Kellen Sedlmayer arrived at Macalester as one. He earned the starting job as a sophomore before hurting his throwing arm early in that campaign and requiring Tommy John surgery, a procedure more often undergone by baseball pitchers.
Sedlmayer was back on the field last fall and he was battling Scully for quarterback starting time during the preseason when he again hurt his dominant wing. Two days later, he was practicing at a new position and in a brace, epitomizing what Nicolaides looks for in team-first attitude.
“He’s a big body and a tough, blue-collar, gritty, scrappy kid,” the coach said of a player who saw action in seven games during 2025. “I have a ton of respect for his character.”
Sedlmayer, 6-feet-2 and 227 pounds, is one of the bigger Scots. The Southern California native suffered a lower-body injury last week but is hoping it’s not serious as he attempts to avoid more sideline time.
“I know how defenses and coverages work and how to run routes accordingly,” said Sedlmayer, an outdoors enthusiast in his spare hours. “At quarterback you’re in control. But at tight end, you have a different job, which is to be ready to hit somebody on every play.”
*****
Seniors eat first at team meals in many programs, but it’s Macalester’s linemen who get the initial shot at chow in appreciation of their often anonymous contributions. A similar reversal occurs when the Scots’ football elders lead in clearing the field of equipment and cleaning the locker room.
Nicolaides places a “servant leader” emphasis on players and coaches and hazing is antithethical to the team’s purpose.
“We have an identify where I’m here to serve my coaches, they’re here to serve the players and the older players are here to serve the younger players,” he said. “Hazing is really bad for morale and not the experience we want. Going to college is a big transition and the first-year guys need the most love and support.”
Notes: Sedlmayer’s alma mater, Sante Fe Christian, requires at least one of a student’s parents to be “a professing believer in Jesus Christ”. Its annual tuition is roughly $30,000 and it has produced a pair of NFL punters… The Scots’ preseason schedule calls for morning practice and several hours of free time and injury rehabilitation after lunch, followed by afternoon meetings. An evening walkthrough on the field emphasizes putting tactics and techniques seen on a white board into physical practice… Nicolaides, in keeping with his kind, has never met an acronym he didn’t like. One of them is TIGERS. It stands for This Is Going to End Really Soon. It was on his mind early this week when he attended the funeral of his paternal grandfather, Thomas Nicolaides, who lived to be 90. “You can look at it as a football season, your college career or your life,” he said. “It’s easy to get lethargic, when we need to be grateful for our health and how cool it is to be out here.”… Brewer played 8-man football at Maine’s Orono High, throwing for 9,025 yards and 125 touchdowns and leading the Red Riots to a state title.


