Benjamin, Blue-Collar Hurricanes Earn 10th Victory

By Tris Wykes

Copyright Octopus Athletics 2025

WHITE RIVER JUNCTION – In retrospect, the Rutland High boys hockey team would have been better off declining Saturday’s interference penalty on Hartford’s Cavan Benjamin with 10 minutes remaining in the Vermont teams’ game at Wendell Barwood Arena. 

You can’t do that in hockey, of course, but the two-minute minor gave Benjamin, a do-everything defenseman, a chance to catch his breath. Which was bad news for the visitors, who soon surrendered a 140-foot Benjamin rush and shot resulting in the winning goal during a 4-3 victory.

Hartford High’s Tyler Spaulding sends Rutland’s Colin Rider flying.

Hartford, the defending Division II champion, trailed, 3-1, after a period and appeared headed for defeat against a Division I foe it beat by four goals in December. Instead, the Hurricanes halved their deficit during the second period and received highlight-reel tallies from senior co-captains Nolan Morlock and Benjamin to improve to 10-4-1.

“We certainly didn’t start on time today,” said 27th-year Hartford coach Todd Bebeau, whose team was outshot, 34-32.. “We were disengaged in that first period. The message between the first and second period was not to panic and if (Rutland) is going to score, make them make hockey plays.

“We gave them gift goals due to our lack of awareness and our lack of structure. We were skating uphill all day long today; it was a grind.”

Recent Hartford teams rarely had to slog to victory. The Hurricanes of the past five years boasted explosive talent on the first two lines, a third line with young, rapidly maturing prospects and even a fourth line that wasn’t a liability if spotted into action. 

The red, white and blue reached the playoff semifinals in 2020 and 2023 and the finals in 2022 and 2024. However, its players sometimes wrestled with off-ice issues, accepting specific roles and handling the expectations that come with being a top-notch team.

 “Our attitude is a lot better than in past years,” said senior forward Logan Caffrey. “We’re not getting on each other when we make a mistake. We lift each other up instead. (Bebeau) loves seeing us play more as a team instead of seeing who can score the most goals.”

Hartford High’s Logan Caffrey (14) jostles with Rutland’s Quincy Bruttomesso.

Said Bebeau: “The reasons why we won this game was the character, maturity and patience we showed.”

Rutland (6-8), which last won a state title in 1995, scored twice in a two-minute span and led, 2-0, with five minutes and 43 seconds remaining in the first period. Morlock got Hartford on the scoreboard less than a minute later but the visitors struck again two minutes before the first intermission.

Nick Daniels pulled the Hurricanes within 3-2 four minutes into the second stanza and Morlock created and capitalized on his own breakaway with nine minutes to play. That set up Benjamin’s winning play, starting when he skated past Rutland’s Brogan Moran and on to a loose puck at his own blue line.

Pressured on his left by Grady Glover, Benjamin held him off with a bent arm and pulled away at the Rutland blue line. Defenseman Zach Melen moved laterally to try and cut Benjamin off, but No. 4 avoided him by pulling the puck back towards his skates and cutting sharply left, giving him a short breakaway against goaltender Noah Bruttomesso. 

The sequence concluded with a shot off the crossbar and into the net, behind which Benjamin lost his footing and fell onto his rear end. It was a rush reminiscent of Boston Bruin legend Bobby Orr, whose most famous score, the 1970 Stanley Cup winner, also ended with him crashing to the ice.

“A bar-down goal,” Bebeau marveled of Benjamin’s strike. “Those were highlight goals and (Morlock and Benjamin) were patient and when their opportunity came, they showed what they were capable of doing.”

Hartford High goaltender Nunu Mayer, who made 31 saves, watches Rutland’s Colin Rider (9).

Benjamin, who also plays soccer and lacrosse and who’s won back-to-back titles in the latter sport, was unquestionably the game’s best player and logged enormous minutes. Tall and rangy, with strength, balance and skill that’s improved dramatically during his high school career, the redhead would have been recognized as dominant even to the newest of hockey fans.

“His reach with his stick is incredible,” Bebeau said. “When you have someone who’s an incredibly talented hockey player and then you add the high-character human being he is, that’s what makes coaching so much fun.

“He is the heart and soul of this hockey team. When you have a good heart and you’re kind to people, good things happen and that’s Cavan Benjamin in a nutshell.”

Caffrey, who played youth hockey with Benjamin, said Saturday wasn’t the first time this winter that his teammate has used a stint in the sin bin to rest up and recharge for scoring forays.

“He’s a beast,” Caffrey said. “When he gets going down the ice, you have to put four or five guys on him, which opens everything up for the rest of us.”

Hartford’s Tyler Spaulding was assessed a five-minute major penalty for a hit from behind with 5:34 remaining, but his teammates held Rutland to only three shots on goal during its man advantage, none of them dangerous. The Hurricanes have a strong penalty kill but sometimes struggle in their own end during full-strength play. 

Hartford High’s Logan Caffrey (14) absorbs a glove to the face from Rutland’s Joseph Kendall.

“We need to have more structure in our defensive zone,” said Bebeau, who wants his troops to move laterally while staying in front of opponents rather than utilizing swooping turns that open gaps in coverage. “Our (second), blue-collar line is doing everything we’re asking of them, but our skill guys need to understand there’s two ends of the ice.

“You win big hockey games in March when you can clamp down on teams with solid defense.”

Hartford received 31 saves from Nunu Mayer and assists from Benjamin, Daniels and freshman Isaac Obar. The Hurricanes visits Colchester (2-10-1) on Wednesday.

Notes: Rutland, which endured controversy and argument over the removal, reinstatement and removal (again) of its “Raiders” nickname, now competes without any moniker… Nick Cameron, a 2019 Hartford graduate who played football, hockey and baseball, now works on the Barwood Arena ice crew… Erin Stevens, Hartford’s top assistant, is in her 12th year with the team… Hurricanes reserve goaltender Frankie Cushing has overcome surgery on both hips… Former Hartford High girls hockey coach Kylie Young, fired without public explanation shortly after guiding the Hurricanes to their first state title last season, is now coaching Dartmouth College’s women’s club team and working as a boys high school referee. She is the Finance and Sports Operations Coordinator for Big Green athletics… James McReynolds, a 20-year old Canaan resident who skated for Hartford and graduated in 2023, has played the last two seasons for the Elmira (N.Y.) Impact’s premier level team, the junior hockey organization’s second-tier club. He has two goals, six assists and 31 penalty minutes in 35 games this winter… Blaine Gour, also a 2023 Hartford graduate, has 20 goals and 18 assists in 30 games for the University of Michigan-Flint’s club team.

-30-

Hartford High’s Cavan Benjamin, second from right, is congratulated after his winning goal.